Insulating existing windows without replacing them: this can mean exterior roller shutters, cellular blinds, thermal roller blinds, insulated curtains, window films or secondary glazing. They are all sold in the language of insulation, warmth or energy saving. But what problem does each actually address – draughts, winter heat loss or summer overheating? These are not the same thing.

I am interested in a second question. A window loses heat in winter, but on a sunny day it can also bring useful energy into the building. Can we improve its insulation at night without unnecessarily sacrificing daylight and solar heat during the day?

Why do product names tell us so little about insulation performance?

A window can be perfectly draught-proof and still lose considerable heat through its glass and frame. Weatherstripping and draught-proofing prevent unwanted air from passing through gaps. Additional insulating layers change heat transfer across the closed window. Solar shading reduces the energy entering from sunlight. One product may serve several purposes, but words such as thermal, energy-saving or reflective are not, by themselves, evidence of tested performance. Q4 M1 M2

The terminology used by sellers adds to the confusion. A thermal pleated blind may be an ordinary single-layer pleated fabric with a coated reverse, whereas a cellular or honeycomb blind has genuine hollow cells between layers. A heat-reflective window film might reduce summer solar gains, or it might reduce the exchange of long-wave thermal radiation. And a window insulation film need not be stuck directly onto the glass at all. What matters is the construction, its position, the air spaces, the edges and the test results for that particular arrangement. M3 M4 M5

Eight options: what do they actually do?

The table is a qualitative decision aid, not a ranking based on invented percentage savings. Here, open or retracted means that the shutter, blind or curtain has been raised or drawn back; the window itself remains closed.

Eight ways to improve the thermal performance of existing windows
Solution and common namesWinter heat lossDaylight and winter sunSummer solar protectionRetrofitting / installationCost informationMain technical limitation
1. Exterior roller shutters (external roller shutters; front-mounted shutters) When closed, an added air layer and enclosure; effectiveness also depends on air leakage Raised: no additional shading from the shutter Exterior position generally makes them particularly effective Retrofittable; shutter box, guides and façade need checking; moderate to substantial work Quotations available; dependent on dimensions and drive Darkness when closed; shutter box and edge gaps matter
2. Cellular or honeycomb blinds / thermal pleated blinds (cellular shades in the US; pleated blinds; DUETTE® is a brand) Honeycomb blinds: air cells; ordinary thermal pleated blinds: often coated fabric; edge guidance matters Raised: view and daylight restored Interior shading; depends on fabric and colour Often straightforward; clip, adhesive or screw fixings Retail prices available Not every ‘thermal pleated blind’ has honeycomb cells
3. Thermal curtains (insulated curtains; thermal-lined curtains; draught-excluding curtains) Fabric and an additional air space; especially dependent on how well the edges close Drawn back: daylight admitted Interior shading, generally less effective than external protection Usually straightforward, with suitable tracks or fittings Retail prices available Airflow behind the curtain; blackout fabric is not proof of insulation
4. Thermal roller blinds (insulating roller shades; reflective roller blinds) Highly dependent on fabric, coating and side guides Raised: daylight admitted Interior shading; reflectance and existing glazing matter Usually simple to moderate Retail prices available ‘Thermal’ is not a defined performance class
5. Window films (low-E films; solar control films; heat-shrink insulation films) Different technologies: low-E applied to glass, or an additional trapped air layer created by frame-mounted film Films bonded to glass remain in the optical path; frame-mounted film is normally left in place until removal Solar control films may be effective, depending on product DIY fitting through to specialist installation; glass compatibility must be assessed Very different across film types and specifications Three distinct subtypes with different operating principles
6. Draught-proofing / weatherstripping (window seals; sealing strips) Reduces air leakage around joints; does not change the glazing's Ug-value Unchanged No shading Often modest work; check seals, fittings and condition Separate material cost from professional fitting Cannot remedy intrinsically poor glazing; ventilation remains necessary
7. Secondary glazing (internal secondary windows; additional glazing panels; interior storm windows in North America) A second glazing layer and an air gap; optional low-E coating Transparent added layer remains in place Limited without further shading Often made to measure; account for space, opening and moisture Individual quotations Condensation, edge seals and access for cleaning
8. Movable FVS multilayer film system (dynamic thermal insulation) Multiple low-E films and air cavities; in-house prototype evidence, no independently certified production-system rating Retracted: no additional shading from FVS Closed: an interior insulating and shading layer; not equivalent to external solar protection Existing-window prototype; production installation is still under development Approx. €20 in the inventor's prototype material costs; not a retail price Edge gaps, mechanism, moisture, durability and whole-window testing remain open

Qualitative comparison only. “Open” means the attachment is raised or retracted; the original window remains closed. Performance depends on the actual assembly, installation and use. The FVS figure relates to prototype materials, not a retail selling price.

How do exterior roller shutters, cellular blinds and thermal pleated blinds compare?

A closed exterior roller shutter creates another layer in front of the window, with air between it and the glazing. Depending on the guides and connections, this air can be retained or exchanged with the surroundings. Anyone considering roller shutters for winter insulation should therefore look beyond the slats and examine the edge seals and shutter box. In summer the main advantage is different: solar radiation is intercepted before it reaches the glass. Q7 M6

A cellular blind – often called a honeycomb blind in the UK or a cellular shade in the US – contains small air cavities. DUETTE® is a Hunter Douglas brand associated with honeycomb blinds, not a generic name for all products of this kind. Manufacturer’s brand information. These blinds can limit heat transfer in winter. Side channels can also reduce air movement between the glazing and the blind. Warm air may rise and cooler air may sink; this natural convection transports heat where the cavities and edge openings permit movement. A thermal pleated blind, by contrast, may consist of just one pleated fabric with a reflective backing. Both may be marketed as insulating blinds, but they are not the same construction. Research on cellular shades demonstrates energy-saving potential under defined test conditions; it does not establish one universal percentage for every home. Q1 M3 M4 M7

What is the difference between thermal curtains and insulating roller blinds?

With thermal curtains, insulated curtains or thermal-lined curtains, fabric weight is not the only consideration. How the curtain closes at the top, sides and bottom is important. If warm indoor air can circulate behind the curtain, part of the insulating effect is bypassed. Blackout curtains, on the other hand, are primarily designed to block light. Blackout fabric may also be insulating, but that does not automatically follow. Thermal and draught-excluding are commercial descriptions, not uniform thermal-resistance classes. Q2 M8

The same principle applies to thermal roller blinds, insulating roller shades or reflective roller blinds. Some are plain dark fabrics, while others have a silvery reflective reverse or side guides. A reflective surface can affect radiative heat exchange, depending on its coating, orientation and the part of the radiation spectrum concerned. But a reflective fabric is not automatically a multilayer air-cavity system. Even an effective interior solar blind does not necessarily perform like an external shutter. M9 Q7

Three types of window film – and why the distinction matters

Terms such as thermal window film, energy-saving film, insulation film and heat-reflective film can refer to very different constructions.

1. Low-emissivity (low-E) film applied directly to the glazing. A low-emissivity surface has a lower emissivity: it emits less long-wave thermal radiation and changes radiative exchange with its surroundings. On suitable glazing, this can reduce winter heat transfer. The film stays on the glass. Depending on the product, it may also affect visible light and transmitted solar energy. Low-E does not automatically mean no loss of solar gain. Q3 M10

2. Solar control and reflective film bonded to glass. Here the principal aim is to reduce incoming solar radiation. Tinted, mirrored and spectrally selective products can reduce glare and summer solar heating to different degrees. A solar control film is therefore not automatically a low-E film designed to improve winter insulation. Conversely, combined-function films do exist. Their lasting effect on solar transmission must also be considered in winter. Q7 M10 M11

3. Transparent heat-shrink window insulation film fitted in front of the glass. This is fixed to the window frame rather than over the full surface of the glazing. It creates an additional air space and is often pulled taut using a hairdryer. Its insulating action is therefore different from that of a coating on the glass itself. One commercial example is tesa INSULATION Film, also marketed in German-speaking markets as tesamoll Thermo Cover. The manufacturer’s instructions explicitly describe the air-cushion arrangement, especially for single-glazed windows. This single, generally seasonal, tensioned film is not a movable FVS with multiple air cavities. M5 tesa English product description

All three approaches require attention to the type of glazing, thermal stress, condensation, cleaning and the ability to operate the window. Compatibility must be checked for the actual glass and film, particularly with coated or multi-pane glazing. Q3 M11

How can draughts be stopped, and when is secondary glazing worthwhile?

If air is entering through a casement seal, a suitable weatherstrip, a replacement rebate seal or an adjustment to the window fittings may be the sensible first step. This reduces uncontrolled air exchange, but does not automatically alter conduction and radiation through old glazing. Airtightness is not the same as thermal insulation. Adequate ventilation is still required after draught-proofing. Q4 M12

Secondary glazing adds another transparent pane or panel on the room side of the existing window. In North America, some related products are described as interior storm windows, although storm window is a broader regional term and can also refer to an external unit. Other constructions use an additional glazed sash, sometimes forming a double-window or box-window arrangement. The intervening air space, potentially combined with low-E glass, provides additional thermal separation. Unlike a retractable blind, the extra glazing normally remains in place. Design must take account of moisture in the cavity, opening clearances and access for cleaning. Q2 M13 Historic England guidance

What makes FVS different – and what does not?

My Folienverbundsystem (FVS) – literally a composite film system, designed here as movable multilayer thermal insulation – is intended to improve an otherwise serviceable existing window. When deployed, several thin, heat-reflective PET films form successive air cavities. Their low-E surfaces reduce long-wave radiative heat exchange; the cavity geometry is intended to restrict air movement. Actual performance also depends on the lateral gaps, edge connections and distance from the glazing. I1 I2 [I3: in-house experiments and prototype documentation; not a public independent test report]

Retracting the film stack removes the additional shading caused by FVS. The original glazing, of course, remains in the path of the sunlight. With suitable orientation, sunshine and a need for heating, useful winter solar gains can then enter again. Roller shutters, pleated blinds and roller blinds can also be moved – movability alone is not unique to FVS. The approach is the combination of several movable low-E films with multiple air cavities. I2 I4

In 2016, Fraunhofer ISE investigated a fixed laboratory specimen with ten PET films metallised on one side and eleven air cavities. My subsequent window-prototype experiments were conducted under different conditions. None of this yet provides an independently verified performance rating for a production FVS window retrofit, nor a direct standardised comparison with every commercial product discussed here. The separately developed Plusenergiefenster is another concept; it must not be confused with an FVS retrofit for an existing window. [I3: in-house experimental documentation; not publicly linked]

Why must U-values, solar gains and costs be considered separately?

A U-value describes heat transfer per unit area and temperature difference. The additional thermal resistance provided by an insulating attachment is not the same as the Uw-value of an entire window. Nor is a measured night-time heat loss equivalent to an annual saving in heating energy. Then there is the g-value, or total solar energy transmittance: it describes the proportion of incident solar energy transmitted through the glazing, including the relevant secondary heat transfer. In North American literature a related measure is the solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC); these values must be interpreted with their respective test definitions. Whether solar heat is useful in winter depends on timing and demand. Q4 I4

Retail prices exist for most established products, but not on a basis that makes the same window size, installation and specification directly comparable. For FVS, my own prototype materials have so far cost approximately €20 per window, including roughly €14 for a basic roller blind that I modify. This is neither a selling price nor a production cost estimate. My aim is for established roller-blind and solar-shading manufacturers eventually to manufacture the system, not to claim that serial production is already proven. [I5: inventor’s own prototype materials record; not a retail quotation]

My conclusion: if you want to insulate an existing window, first identify the problem – draughts, winter heat loss or summer overheating – and then look at the construction. A word such as thermal tells you surprisingly little. What interests me is where the construction restricts heat transfer while the way it is operated allows useful solar heat back in at the right moment.


Further reading in English


References and evidence

The source labels above link directly to the relevant material. Research and public technical guidance support physical principles; manufacturers’ and retailers’ pages primarily document product constructions and terminology, not universal energy-saving rates. Evidence for FVS prototypes and materials costs comes from the inventor’s own work. Original German-language references are retained where they are the underlying source.

Research and independent technical guidance

Manufacturer, retailer and market-terminology examples

I[n]solation evidence and own work

Editorial status: 15 November 2026. No new measurements, calculations, performance guarantees or product prices have been introduced. Prepared for approval; not yet published on WordPress.