A building’s energy mystery — can you solve it?

I[n]solation · Knowledge & Perspectives

Original articles on windows, dynamic thermal protection and the energy transition.

English originals
Façades · Solar Energy & Thermal Mass
Summer · Heat & Comfort
Retrofit · Costs & Measured Performance

German author library · Technical articles

A building’s energy mystery — can you solve it?

To understand what an energy retrofit actually achieves, we need to know how much energy the building really uses. But sometimes the mystery starts before the retrofit. Take this apartment building in Rüsselsheim, Germany: three adjoining sections, built at the same time, with the same construction and the same living area. The key figures are in the image. Can you match each section to its gas consumption? You might expect the middle section to win. Unlike its neighbours, it has no exposed end wall. But here is what the meters showed: North: 168. Middle: 125. South: 99 kWh/m²/year. The northern section used almost 70% more gas than the southern one. The two outer sections have one obvious difference: one end wall faces north, the other south. So let’s look beyond the U-value and consider the wall as a potential solar collector. Solar heat does not have to reach the room to help with heating. Warming the outside surface can already reduce heat escaping through the wall. For a rough estimate, we use a difference in solar irradiation between south- and north-facing walls of around 331 kWh/m² over the October–April heating season. Let’s assume that roughly 60% of this difference helps reduce the heating demand. That gives a possible contribution of: ≈ 199 kWh per m² of end wall. Now compare that with the gas readings. The annual difference between the northern and southern sections was around 32,000 kWh of gas. Spread over an estimated 120 m² of end wall enclosing heated rooms, and assuming a seasonal efficiency of 70–75% for the old individual gas heaters, that corresponds to: ≈ 187–200 kWh of useful heat per m² of end wall. Our rough solar estimate: around 199. Estimated from the gas readings: 187–200. Surprisingly close. Does that solve the mystery? Not yet. The match depends on our assumptions. Indoor temperatures, ventilation, hot-water use, residents’ heating habits and possibly additional electric heaters could also have contributed to the difference. But the wall’s orientation is a clue worth following. Building and consumption data: IWU, Enseling/Hinz (2009), Holbeinstraße 3–5–7. Solar comparison: my own rough estimate. Source link and further details in the first comment.
Direct link to this original article